When you look at the research provided by Roy Baumeister and others, it is apparent self-esteem is not suitable for you or anyone. Buy his book Willpower and check out chapter 9. Despite good research like his, self-esteem continues to be as popular as ever. It is a key principle taught by self-help gurus, counselors, and most of our education system. It is something that great leaders do not depend on.
If you want another option to reading Willpower, below is a link to a sermon. It looks at self-esteem and self-governance from a biblical perspective. The title is "Satan Loves This, Do You?" Click this link to download the document.
GR8 Leaders promote something far better than self-esteem.
There is a famous experiment done originally by Dr. Walter Mischel in the late 1960s. A young child was asked to sit at a table by themselves in a room. An adult came into the room and told them, "Here is a marshmallow. You can eat it now, or if you wait for 10 minutes, I will give you two marshmallows to eat." The adult repeated the statement at least one additional time to make sure the child understood. The adult would then leave the room.
Videos of children are funny and what you would expect. Some children waited, and others didn't. The antics of the children trying not to eat the marshmallow range from stoic to highly active as they try to distract their attention from the marshmallow.
Here is a link to a short video if you have yet to see the experiment.
Since research shows that self-esteem doesn't work for the good of society, what does?
There is something that consistently shows up. People with higher grades, higher levels of income, lower addictions, higher productivity, less sexual promiscuity, and fewer teenage pregnancies have that something. Actually, the list of positive elements is longer.
What makes the big difference in the kids who did not eat the marshmallows? The marshmallow video provides the answer. The video is cute and fun, but here is “the rest of the story.”
Many years after Dr. Mischel did the original Marshmallow Tests, his children convinced him to research what happened to the children in the original experiment. He found the ones who had shown the most willpower at age 4. They...
The research says those traits could be genetic, but it also shows a strong link to the nurture and development of the child’s self-control. That is a dividend paid back to the child throughout their life. (Willpower p11)
Consider this sidebar. Despite all of the self-esteem psycho-babble, most of the video game industry does not believe that message. As with life, you start as an inexperienced newbie and only move forward after you achieve specific outcomes and proficiency. Yes, there are lousy values and bad morals in many of the games, but that is another issue.
Despite that, the one thing they have right is they teach some clear elements of self-control. You need clear goals to achieve, a way to measure progress, and clarity about how you compare to others doing the same thing. Those are clear, straightforward ways to build self-control.
Additionally, the results from both self-governance and self-esteem are vastly different. The research has plenty to provide evidence for each of the following columns.
Look at how the above items appear in society now, especially numbers 4-9 immediately above. Unfortunately, all items in the left column are easy to see now. That behavior is part of our elementary schools, high schools, college campuses, and governing bodies in Washington, D.C.
Roy Baumeister, in his book Willpower, says, "The theory of self-esteem was a well-intentioned attempt to use psychology for the public good, and it indeed seemed promising at first." He was an early proponent of self-esteem. However, years of research show no correlation between increased good for society and self-esteem.
Here is one of his most important conclusions:
“On the whole, benefits of high self-esteem accrue to the self while its costs are borne by others, who must deal with side effects like arrogance and conceit. At worst, self-esteem becomes narcissism, the self-absorbed conviction of personal superiority. Narcissists are legends in their own mind…”
And you can find many articles discussing the dangers and the results of focusing on self-esteem. Here are some older ones to show that people have been concerned about this, and research has been around for years to show that it doesn’t work.
WASHINGTON—My personal gag instinct has now been reinforced by reams of genuine psychological studies indicating that high self-esteem...is not the fount of nirvana, and low self-esteem is not the root of all evil. New, serious studies have found that rapists and robbers are as likely to think highly of themselves as dentists and dockworkers. …the London School of Economics...
Dr. Nicholas Emler's research found no clear link between low self-esteem and behaviors we automatically associate with low self-esteem – juvenile delinquency, teen smoking, drug use or racism. "There is absolutely no evidence that low self-esteem is particularly harmful," Emler said.
…The self-esteem lobby has infiltrated pedagogy and parenting in a huge way. Stacks of books tell parents to tell their kids that they’re special. Teachers too. The kids might not be taught to spell “special” but special they are. We’re all special. The new research on self-esteem suggests that all this isn’t just silliness. Unchallenged self-esteem therapies used in real life to attack problems like teen pregnancy, juvenile crime and alcohol abuse are probably sapping time and energy from far more productive responses.
…I’ll go way out on a limb here and say that it’s better to teach a growing Self skills like discipline, control, tenacity, charity, manners, sportsmanship and math than it is to teach a Self to chant, “I’m special and I love myself every day and in every way.” …Often it's those things that take us outside of our own Selves and into communities or other people’s needs that are most therapeutic – religion, volunteer work, mentoring, teaching, coaching, cheering on your team.
WASHINGTON—…From childhood on, Americans are told by “experts” – therapists, self-esteem educators, grief counselors, traumatologists – that it is healthy for them continuously to take their emotional temperature, inventory their feelings and vent them.
…Because children are considered terribly vulnerable and fragile, playground games like dodge ball are being replaced by anxiety-reducing and self-esteem-enhancing games of tag where nobody is ever “out.” But abundant research indicates no connection between high self-esteem and high achievement or virtue.
…Sensitivity screeners remove from texts and tests distressing references to things like rats, snakes, typhoons, blizzards and … birthday parties (which might distress children who do not have them). The sensitivity police favor teaching what Sommers and Satel call “no-fault history.” Hence California’s Department of Education stipulating that when “ethnic or cultural groups are portrayed, portrayals must not depict differences in customs or lifestyles as undesirable” – slavery? segregation? anti-Semitism? cannibalism? – “and must not reflect adversely on such differences.”
Experts warn about what children are allowed to juggle: Tennis balls cause frustration, where-as “scarves are soft, nonthreatening, and float down slowly.” …Remember the theory that because Vietnam was supposedly an unjust war, it would produce an epidemic of “post-traumatic stress disorders.” So a study released in 1990 claimed that half of Vietnam veterans suffered from some PTSD – even though only 15 percent of Vietnam veterans had served in combat units.
An elementary school teacher was teaching her class about heroes, so she asked her class of 25 to name their heroes. The first little girl stood up and provided a list of Madonna, Michael Jackson, and Boy George. The next student was a boy, and he quickly named Michael Jackson, Spiderman, and Superman. And so it went around the room.
None of those answers surprised her; in fact, she expected it. What was extremely surprising was to hear who eight of the children named. No, it wasn’t another rock star, and certainly not Andrew Jackson, George Washington, Charles Lindbergh, or Thomas Edison.
The surprising, even shocking thing, was they named themselves as heroes. It is one thing to replace the figures of Mt. Rushmore with rock stars; that’s bad enough, but to replace them with yourself is a sad indictment of a self-absorbed society.
The above are a few of the many that you can find. A few more are included in the GR8 Relationships study guide in chapter 6.
Tags
difference between self-esteem and self-control, marshmallow test, self-control, self-esteem, self-governance, willpower
If you desire to lead, you must have six critical leadership values. You can only be a great leader if you have great values. Unfortunately, great values are highly underrated. But those values make the difference between being a GOOD or BAD leader. As a leader, when you subject your leadership to the six critical leader
Read MoreAre you focused on job satisfaction or typical human resource items? If you want employee satisfaction, focus on 6 work-enriching principles. Why is so much time spent on things that will not increase job satisfaction? Because it takes time and energy to focus on items that really do impact job satisfaction. The 6 work enriching principles
Read More